Pierce wins in razor-thin margin in Kenai borough mayoral runoff

Updated | 11:24 a.m. Nov. 1

After a long, contentious race, the Kenai Peninsula Borough has a new mayor: Charlie Pierce.

After a runoff last week, Pierce held on through a count of a record number of absentee ballots to win by 45 votesover Linda Farnsworth-Hutchings.

“Oh, boy oh boy. It’s really close and I’m just really humbled,” Pierce said.

“It tells me that either my base didn’t turn out or this community is divided on the issues.”

Pierce campaigned on a promise to dig into the borough’s finances to find a way to trim back spending to close the borough’s $4 million budget gap. In the end, Pierce garnered 4,301 votes to Hutchings’ 4,256.

Original story | 12:26 p.m. Oct. 30

Residents of the Kenai Peninsula Borough are waiting for the mailman to help sort out whether Charlie Pierce or Linda Farnsworth-Hutchings will be the new borough mayor.

Any qualified absentee ballots postmarked by Oct. 24 that arrive at the borough building in the mail today or tomorrow are eligible to be added to the final tally of votes in the runoff election for Kenai Peninsula Borough mayor.

Only then can the final results be presented for certification to the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly, which will happen at its Tuesday night meeting, according to Borough Clerk Johni Blankenship.

“We will transfer any ballots that come in the mail to the canvass board. They will review those for eligibility. If anything is valid, they will run, or count, those,” she said. “We will present a resolution with the election results to the Assembly for consideration to certify the election.”

On Friday, the canvass board counted 1,651 absentee ballots, with Farnsworth-Hutchings taking 54 percent, reducing the 223-vote lead Pierce has held since polls closed Tuesday night, to 51 votes.

Blankenship says runoff elections don’t usually attract as many absentee ballots as this one has.

“The runoff is, as far as the number of absentees, both in-person and by mail, this particular runoff has been standard to a regular election. So it’s pretty high for a runoff election,” she said. “The last election we had on Oct. 3, the absentees, the number there was unprecedented. It was 3,000 – over 3,000.”

So until the mailman arrives, Pierce has 4,296 votes to Farnsworth-Hutchings’ 4,245, a difference of 51 votes, or six-tenths of one percent of the votes cast in the runoff election.

Sign up for The Signal

Top Alaska stories delivered to your inbox every week

Site notifications
Update notification options
Subscribe to notifications