The City and Borough of Juneau Assembly turned down a $2 million donation from the Norwegian Cruise Line company during its regular meeting Monday night.
Some assembly members were concerned about what the public would think of the city taking the money.
In May, Norwegian announced it would donate a total of $10 million to Alaska port communities. That included Ketchikan, Juneau, Hoonah, Sitka, Skagway and Seward. The funds were intended to support small businesses and those most impacted by the lack of cruise passengers last year.
To provide relief to the Alaskan port communities we’re donating $10M dollars & partnering with @voyijtravel to support local small businesses. Directly purchase products from locally caught fish to Native Art!
Shop here: https://t.co/1j19WyhQ20
More info: https://t.co/HNgXLbB36f pic.twitter.com/8lLxtE9QT0
— Cruise Norwegian (@CruiseNorwegian) May 4, 2021
The company has purchased an empty waterfront lot downtown, where it wants to build a dock.
Carole Triem is one of six assembly members who voted against taking the donation. She said the proposed dock factored heavily in her decision.
“The whole process from start to finish requires decision-making from the assembly,” Triem said. “I just think that to accept money from NCL, even though it’s totally separate from the decisions we’d be making about this development project just is not a good look for us.”
Triem said even though she has faith in everyone involved, just the appearance of impropriety is enough to lose the public’s trust.
During the meeting, assembly member Wade Bryson disagreed with that argument.
“The opposition to the dock is still going to be there,” Bryson said. “The pro-tourism groups are still going to be there. Taking that $2 million changes not one number on either side of that equation.”
Bryson added that the path for Norwegian getting its dock is already in city code and charted out.
“Yes, I would agree that we have to make a couple of decisions along the way, but they’re not going to be able to come up with some strategy or technique that’s going to help them circumvent the Juneau process,” Bryson said. “It would be foolish and fiscally irresponsible to reject this money that is going to go, at our decision, to helping our community.”
Ultimately, the motion failed by a six to three vote and the assembly asked City Manager Rorie Watt to go back to Norwegian, suggesting the company donate directly to an organization like the Juneau Community Foundation, instead of the city itself.