Transgender state employee wins lawsuit over sexual reassignment surgery costs

A Juneau woman who sued the state of Alaska for sex discrimination won her case on Friday.

Jennifer Fletcher is a state legislative librarian. She’s also transgender. And she paid thousands in out-of-pocket costs for surgical treatment, because the state’s health insurance won’t cover sexual reassignment surgery for transgender employees.

Fletcher and her lawyers at Lambda Legal said that this violates Title VII — the federal civil rights law that prohibits sex discrimination. They argued that the surgeries she wanted to get would have been covered if she weren’t transgender — and that’s discrimination based on her sex.

They argued that a federal ban on sex discrimination includes discrimination based on gender nonconformity, gender identity, transgender status and gender transition.

The state argued that its denial of coverage for Fletcher’s surgery wasn’t discriminatory because it was not motivated by her sex. It’s a blanket policy that applies equally to men and women.

But U.S. District Court Judge H. Russel Holland agreed with Fletcher. However, the decision could be appealed to a higher court.

Fletcher wrote in a message Friday that she hopes this decision will keep other people “like me from having to face these same struggles, from being harmed by being singled out for discriminatory treatment. I hope it will make their lives easier.”

Reader Interactions

X