The Race Where Race Didn’t Matter

District Attorney Dan Donovan celebrates after his win in a special election to Congress from Staten Island, N.Y. Julie Jacobson/AP
District Attorney Dan Donovan celebrates after his win in a special election to Congress from Staten Island, N.Y.
Julie Jacobson/AP

The Staten Island prosecutor who was at the heart of the investigation into the death of Eric Garner at police hands last year was overwhelmingly elected to Congress Tuesday night.

In the special election in New York’s 11th District to replace disgraced former Rep. Michael Grimm, R-N.Y., Republican District Attorney Daniel Donovan cruised to a nearly 20-point win over the Democratic nominee, New York City Councilman Vincent Gentile.

Donovan was the heavy favorite in the GOP-leaning district, despite the controversy that had surrounded him after the death of Garner, the 43-year-old African-American who died last July in a police chokehold. Garner was under suspicion of selling loose cigarettes.

His death was captured on video, and added to the tension across the country after a series of deadly standoffs between police and black men in Ferguson, Mo., Cleveland, and now Baltimore this past month. Donovan impaneled the grand jury that ultimately declined to press charges against the police officers in the incident. Protests and riots in New York City and beyond followed after the decision.

But despite the controversy, Democrats didn’t use the Garner case to attack Donovan. That’s because in the working-class, police-heavy borough trying to leverage the case could have backfired. National Democrats didn’t play in the special election, and Gentile was heavily outraised by Donovan.

Democrats have a glimmer of hope in trying to knock off Donovan during the regular 2016 general election, though, when they anticipate former New York Sen. Hillary Clinton will be atop the ticket. President Obama narrowly won the district, which includes all of Staten Island and a sliver of Brooklyn, in 2012. Four years earlier, Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., won there.

The 11th district and Staten Island are the most conservative of the city’s boroughs, and that’s largely how Grimm — who was under a 20-count indictment last November for charges ranging from tax fraud to perjury — was still able to win reelection. He eventually pleaded guilty to one felony charge as part of a plea deal and resigned his House seat in January.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit
Read Original Article – Published MAY 06, 201512:34 PM ET

NPR News

KTOO is the NPR member station in Juneau. NPR offers its members radio and digital stories.

Site notifications
Update notification options
Subscribe to notifications