Peter Tony sentenced to 66 years in prison without parole

Peter Tony was sentenced to 66 years in prison. (Photo by Ben Matheson / KYUK)

Peter Tony was sentenced to 66 years in prison. (Photo by Ben Matheson / KYUK)

Former Bethel foster parent Peter Tony will spend the rest of his life in prison. Tony was sentenced Tuesday to 66 years in jail with no parole for three consolidated child sex abuse counts in which he pleaded guilty.

Superior Court Judge Douglas Blankenship sentenced the 70-year-old in a two-and-a-half hour hearing with a few victims and families in the room. After Tony did not completely understand the complicated proceedings, Blankenship put it simply for him and the courtroom.

“But you’re a predator and too dangerous to society, so what the court’s intention is, is to keep you in jail until the end of your life,” said Blankenship.

In a February deal with prosecutors, Tony pleaded guilty to charges of sexually abusing a minor in 2012 when he abused a 4-year-old his wife had in day care. He also pleaded guilty to molesting a 12-year old girl in 1998.

Tony’s stepdaughter, Kimberley Bruesch says she was abused by Tony years ago and spoke to the court, saying she hoped other victims would be validated by the sentence. Afterwards she said she’s found closure and added the length of the sentence doesn’t make a difference to her.

“It’s not going to bring my sisters back,” said Bruesch.

Bruesch’s two sisters were abused by Tony and later committed suicide. In considering Tony’s sentence, the judge silently read through one sister’s suicide note that mentioned the abuse. But Tony isn’t going to jail for that abuse decades ago, but for more recent cases.

The court says Tony had been abusing since the early ‘70s. No one knows exactly how many victims, but Tony admitted to “a few.” His stepdaughter, Bruesch says state agencies bear a large part of the blame and says she first reported the abuse in 1982.

“There are agencies that could have perhaps helped him or held him accountable sooner, maybe there would have been that possibility of rehabilitation 30 or 40 years ago, had they done their job. But not only they did they fail to take action based on reports they had received, they licensed him as a foster parent, they continued to ignore one report after another and continued to entrust more children to him,” said Breusch.

Before running a small daycare out of their home, the Tony and his late wife Marylin had been foster parents for 14 years, between 1984 and 1998 at which point they lost their license from the state after a substantiated claim, according to the Alaska Dispatch. There was no report to police at that time, to the knowledge of corporal Amy Davis with the Bethel Police Department. She began investigating in early 2013.

The 66-year sentence is longer than that the 50 years the state actually asked for. Prosecutor Chris Carpeneti said the prospect of rehabilitation for Tony “simply did not exist.” Public Defender Mark Osterman asked for a smaller sentence.

“I think under the circumstances, Mr. Tony is redeemable, and I don’t think the court should throw away the key,” said Osterman.

In handcuffs and a yellow jumpsuit, Tony made a brief statement, saying he grew up without a father and with no guidance. He said drinking had caught up with him and that he was never good in social situations. He apologized after being prompted by his attorney.

“To those I am really very sorry, there’s no words that could really say, not to my knowledge anyway, that I am sorry those things happened,” said Tony.

Tony was sentenced to two 36-year prison terms with 6 years suspended in one case, and 10 years with 4 suspended in another for the total of 66 years to be served. He also got at least 15 years probation, which the judge said is not going to be relevant at Tony’s age . Prosecution indicated that it will be seeking restitution for victims.

Recent headlines

  • (Creative Commons photo by Velkr0/Flickr)

    Ask the Energy Desk: Are plastic bag bans better for the environment?

    Bans on plastic grocery bags have been cropping up across Alaska’s remote communities. Cordova’s ban went into effect last year. But so far, the larger cities in the state have yet to adopt one.
  • The Haines state trooper car parked outside of the courthouse. (Photo by Emily Files/KHNS)

    Alaska State Troopers plan to move Haines position to Bethel

    Things are not looking good for Haines’ Alaska State Trooper post. Trooper Director Col. James Cockrell intends to reassign Haines’ one trooper position to Bethel. The decision isn’t final yet, but the community conversation about how to handle the loss continued at a Public Safety Commission meeting this week.
  • Study shows rise in some prenatal exposure to opiates

    A new study from a Alaskan epidemiologist looks at infants who were exposed to opiates before birth. Unlike previous studies, it goes beyond the sharp rise in cases for a portion of the population to explore what happens next.
  • The dark areas are pink salmon between the falls in the Anan Creek south of Wrangell, Alaska. (Photo courtesy Troy Thynes)

    State cuts bring changes to Southeast commercial fisheries

    Commercial fisheries in Southeast Alaska have survived two years of state budget cuts but not without some changes. The Alaska Department of Fish and Game’s Division of Commercial Fisheries has cut some positions, ended some monitoring programs, and found some new funding sources.
X