Supreme Court Rules Against Patents For Abstract Ideas

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled unanimously Thursday that using a computer to implement an abstract idea does not make that invention eligible for a patent.

At issue in the case, Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International: Do software inventions get the same kind of patent protections as other inventions?

The justices, in their decision, upheld a lower court ruling that invalidated Alice Corp.’s patents, which were challenged by CLS International. But, as SCOTUSblog notes: “[T]he Supreme Court leaves room for software patents, just not those that take an abstract idea and provide for a computer to implement it.”

The Associated Press reports:

“The justices ruled unanimously that the government should not have issued a patent to Alice Corp. in the 1990s because the company simply took an abstract idea that has been around for years and programmed it to run through a computer.

“The decision makes clear that to obtain a patent, a company’s idea must actually improve how a computer functions or make other technical advancements.”

And here’s more from SCOTUSblog on the impact of the decision: “The case is more of a stepping stone than pathbreaking.”

Technology companies like Google and Facebook were closely watching the case and had urged clearer rules for software patents.

NPR’s Laura Sydell reported last month on the case, providing some background:

“Alice Corp. owns patents on a process of verifying payment on a computer. The company says it’s a special method. Alice Corp. is what is called a nonpracticing entity — known pejoratively as a ‘patent troll.’ ”

“They don’t in fact sell a software or a program,” Mark Lemley, a law professor at Stanford University, told Laura.

He said Alice Corp. claims it has a patent on using a computer to confirm a financial transaction and says anyone using a computer process to do this should pay the company a fee. That’s what CLS Bank, which settles foreign exchange transactions, had challenged. On Thursday, the court sided with CLS.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.image
Read original article – Published June 19, 201411:55 AM ET
Supreme Court Rules Against Patents For Abstract Ideas

Recent headlines

  • Computer problems for some - extended coffee break for others: Some employees of the Dept. of Commerce, Community and Economic Development, Financial Services Division in the State Office Building in Juneau drink coffee near their disabled computers March 22, 2017. The workers, who chose to not be identified, said that some computers were working while others were not as a result of a statewide technical problem within the state's system. (Photo by Skip Gray/360 North)

    Software update locks thousands of state workers out of computers

    Roughly 6,000 state workers were unable to log in to their computers, affecting two in five executive branch workers.
  • The top of the Raven Shark totem pole lies in Totem Hall at Sitka National Historical Park. (Photo by Emily Russell/KCAW)

    After 30 years, Raven Shark pole back in Sitka

    The totem pole is an icon of the Pacific Northwest. The carved art form showcases clan stories and family crests in museums around the world. After more than 30 years in the Anchorage Museum, a century-old pole from Southeast has made it back to Sitka, where curators are prepping a permanent home.
  • Longtime leader Rosita Worl to leave Sealaska board

    One of the Sealaska regional Native corporation’s longest-serving leaders is stepping down. Rosita Worl says she will not run for another term after 30 years on the board.
  • U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, speaks to reporters in one of the Senate’s more ornate rooms. (Photo by Liz Ruskin/Alaska Public Media)

    Murkowski at odds with Trump’s call to end NEA funding

    President Donald Trump’s budget outline calls for eliminating funding for the National Endowment for the Arts. The NEA has been a frequent target of Republicans, but U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski supports the endowment, and Tuesday she won the 2017 Congressional Arts Leadership Award.
X