Appeals court orders new assessment of arctic lease sale

Shell's Kulluk drill rig

Shell Oil’s Kulluk drill rig in Dutch Harbor last summer. Photo courtesy Shell Oil.

A federal appeals court has ruled that the environmental assessment behind a massive oil lease sale off Alaska’s northern coast is faulty.

The ruling from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals applies to a Chukchi Sea lease sale from 2008. But it’s cast a pall on the future of Arctic oil exploration.

Erik Grafe is an attorney for EarthJustice. He’s argued the case through several rounds of appeals on behalf of environmental groups, and the Alaska Native communities of Point Hope and the North Slope.

In this most recent appeal, Grafe set out to prove that the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management miscalculated how much oil would be produced in the Chukchi Sea.

At first, BOEM tried to peg potential development to the price of oil. But that was complicated. So the agency ended up choosing 1 billion barrels as the likely output.

BOEM studied the risk of oil spills based on that level of development. Grafe says it determined “the number of exploration wells that the agency said would result from the lease sale, the number of drilling rigs that would be in the ocean because of the lease sale.”

Grafe argued that the 1 billion barrel benchmark was an arbitrary choice. And the appeals court agreed. Now, they’re sending BOEM back to re-assess development in the Chukchi Sea.

The price of oil has gone up, so Grafe says BOEM’s new study will probably be based on a higher level of activity and production. And that could prompt a major reevaluation of Arctic drilling.

“The agency has to reconsider the lease sale — whether to hold the lease sale, whether it should open the Chukchi Sea to oil and gas drilling leases — in light of that new analysis that takes a proper look at the potential environmental impacts,” Grafe says.

The court stopped short of invalidating the 2008 lease sale. Shell Oil submitted a new exploration plan for its Chukchi Sea leases, but the company hadn’t announced whether they intended to return this year.

Now, it’s not clear if they can. Michael LeVine is with Oceana, one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit.

“Allowing a company to drill exploration wells on leases that were improvidently awarded is not good governance,” LeVine says. “We hope that that will not be allowed.”

BOEM and the leaseholders named as defendants — Shell, ConocoPhillips and Statoil — have the option to request a re-hearing of the case in appeals court.

BOEM declined to comment. In a statement, Shell said only, “We are reviewing the opinion.”

Recent headlines

  • Acting Alaska U.S. Attorney Bryan Schroder speaks at a press conference in Anchorage on March 23, 2017.

    Veteran prosecutor nominated to be the US attorney in Alaska

    Trump nominated Bryan Schroder for the post, the acting head of the Alaska district since Karen Loeffler and 45 other U.S. attorneys appointed by former President Barack Obama were asked to resign after Trump's election.
  • The Alaska Capitol Building in Juneau on June 6, 2017. (Photo by Jeremy Hsieh/KTOO)

    Alaska lawmakers to reconvene on capital budget next week

    A Senate spokesman says the third special session is likely to start Thursday, July 27, in Juneau, and it's expected to last one or two days. The House and Senate indicated an agreement had been reached.
  • A robotic camera provides for wildlife tracking across a meadow near the Mendenhall Glacier Visitors Center for Wild Alaska Live. (Photo by Mikko Wilson/KTOO)

    Behind the scenes of Wild Alaska Live

    The BBC and PBS are teaming up on a special series of live, prime-time nature programs showcasing Alaska’s wildlife to tens of millions people around the world. Cutting edge technology and a lot of luck goes into the high stakes production.
  • Greens Creek Mine

    Juneau Assembly mining task force to add members

    The three-member Juneau Assembly mining task force is seeking to add two planning commissioners and two members of the public. The group is studying a proposal to streamline the city's mining review process.