Report Details Industry’s ‘Cutthroat’ Fight Of Miners’ Claims

By October 30, 2013NPR News

My investigative reporting colleague Chris Hamby at the Center for Public Integrity has a compelling and troubling follow-up to our jointly-reported series last year on the resurgence of the deadly coal miners’ disease black lung.

Hamby has spent the last year investigating the system that awards compensation to miners stricken with the disease. He found that miners face a concerted industry effort to deny compensation payments, which includes industry-hired lawyers withholding evidence favorable to miners and doctors at a major university “helping to defeat the claims of sick miners.”

The series “Breathless and Burdened” began Tuesday with a detailed look at the “cutthroat approach” of the industry’s “go-to law firm” for fighting black lung claims. Wednesday stories on the CPI website and ABC’s World News and Nightline focus on the role of doctors at one of the nation’s top-ranked university hospitals in rejecting claims. Friday, Hamby’s series concludes with reports on the “the latest industry effort to defuse emerging scientific evidence and contain its liabilities.”

In the first installment Tuesday, Hamby writes that “the role of lawyers in orchestrating sophisticated legal strategies to defeat claims for benefits is just the first chapter in the story of a system in which well-paid specialists thrive as miners struggle…”

In a “behind the story” sidebar, Hamby says, “it is difficult to imagine someone more voiceless or whose suffering is more silent than the Appalachian coal miner.”

He found that black lung victims and their advocates had a widespread sense “that the deck was stacked against them. Many simply stopped bothering with what they considered a system gone horribly awry.”

The reports are exhaustive, drawing on legal documents, hundreds of thousands of pages of medical records, and spreadsheets Hamby created to track and analyze thousands of cases.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit
Read original article – Published October 29, 2013 5:01 PM
Report Details Industry’s ‘Cutthroat’ Fight Of Miners’ Claims

Recent headlines

  • (Creative Commons photo by Velkr0/Flickr)

    Ask the Energy Desk: Are plastic bag bans better for the environment?

    Bans on plastic grocery bags have been cropping up across Alaska’s remote communities. Cordova’s ban went into effect last year. But so far, the larger cities in the state have yet to adopt one.
  • The Haines state trooper car parked outside of the courthouse. (Photo by Emily Files/KHNS)

    Alaska State Troopers plan to move Haines position to Bethel

    Things are not looking good for Haines’ Alaska State Trooper post. Trooper Director Col. James Cockrell intends to reassign Haines’ one trooper position to Bethel. The decision isn’t final yet, but the community conversation about how to handle the loss continued at a Public Safety Commission meeting this week.
  • Study shows rise in some prenatal exposure to opiates

    A new study from a Alaskan epidemiologist looks at infants who were exposed to opiates before birth. Unlike previous studies, it goes beyond the sharp rise in cases for a portion of the population to explore what happens next.
  • The dark areas are pink salmon between the falls in the Anan Creek south of Wrangell, Alaska. (Photo courtesy Troy Thynes)

    State cuts bring changes to Southeast commercial fisheries

    Commercial fisheries in Southeast Alaska have survived two years of state budget cuts but not without some changes. The Alaska Department of Fish and Game’s Division of Commercial Fisheries has cut some positions, ended some monitoring programs, and found some new funding sources.